Gear, Walks & Safety βœ“ Evidence-Based & Fact-Checked

The Best Chew Toys for Teething Puppies, Ranked for Safety

Transparency Disclosure: DaisyDu is reader-supported. When you purchase pet gear through links on our site (such as Amazon), we may earn an affiliate commission at zero extra cost to you. Learn more.

Best chew toys for teething puppies

For most teething puppies, the best chew toys for teething puppies are soft rubber toys sized to the puppy, with a freezable option for sore gums and a firmer puppy nylon toy for determined chewers. Our top pick is the KONG Puppy Goodie Bone, because it is gentle on baby teeth, stuffable, and easy for small paws to hold.

Best chew toys for teething puppies are the ones your puppy will actually chew without hurting its mouth. That sounds obvious, but the shelf is full of toys made for adult jaws, and a toy that is too hard can crack a baby tooth, while a toy that is too soft shreds in minutes and becomes a swallowing risk. This guide compares four puppy specific toys on softness, size, freezing, and supervision needs, so you can pick one with confidence instead of guessing in the aisle.

Heads up: the links below go to Amazon product pages. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

Our Picks at a Glance

ToyMaterialBest forFreezable
KONG Puppy Goodie BoneSoft puppy rubberMost puppiesYes, stuff and freeze
Nylabone Puppy Chew Ring BoneSoft puppy nylonDetermined chewersYes
Petstages Cool Teething StickCotton poly fabricSore gumsYes, soak and freeze
Benebone Puppy 2-PackSofter puppy nylonPups who destroy rubberNo

KONG Puppy Goodie Bone: Best Overall

Top pick

KONG Puppy Goodie Bone

The Goodie Bone uses KONG’s soft puppy rubber, made for a mouth full of baby teeth rather than an adult jaw. Its bone shape is easy to hold between small paws, and the grippers let you stuff it with puppy snacks or paste, which turns a simple chew into a longer, calmer activity. Buyer feedback consistently praises it as a first toy that survives daily use without being rock hard.

Pros
  • Soft rubber made for baby teeth
  • Stuffable for longer engagement
  • Easy shape for small paws to hold
  • Widely available in puppy sizes
Cons
  • Determined chewers may outgrow it fast
  • Rubber smell puts some owners off at first
  • Needs sizing up once adult teeth arrive

Check Current Price

Nylabone Puppy Chew Ring Bone: Best for Determined Chewers

Nylabone Puppy Chew Ring Bone

This ring bone uses Nylabone’s softest puppy material, and it is designed for puppies without adult teeth. The ring shape lets a puppy work the toy with its back teeth, the ridges massage gums, and the whole toy can go in the freezer for extra relief. Buyer feedback highlights its durability for puppies that shred soft rubber in an afternoon, with the usual warning to retire it once pieces wear down.

Pros
  • Puppy soft nylon, not adult hardness
  • Ring shape reaches back teeth
  • Freezer friendly for sore gums
  • Ridges help clean teeth as puppies chew
Cons
  • Not for powerful chewers or puppies with adult teeth
  • Flavor fades with heavy use
  • Must be checked often for worn edges

Check Current Price

Petstages Cool Teething Stick: Best for Sore Gums

Petstages Cool Teething Stick

When gums are at their worst, cold beats hardness. This fabric stick soaks in water and freezes into a crunchy, cooling chew that soothes without stressing baby teeth. It is a supervised only toy: once it thaws and softens, take it away and refreeze it. Buyer feedback loves it for peak teething days and hot weather, and is clear that it is not a leave on the floor all day toy.

Pros
  • Freezable cold relief for sore gums
  • Soft fabric, gentle on baby teeth
  • Crunchy texture keeps puppies interested
  • Good value as a second toy
Cons
  • Supervised use only, not for unsupervised chewing
  • Needs refreezing after it thaws
  • Strong chewers can shred fabric

Check Current Price

Benebone Puppy 2-Pack: Best for Pups Who Destroy Rubber

Benebone Puppy 2-Pack

Benebone’s puppy version uses a softer nylon than its adult chews, with a wishbone shape puppies can grip and real bacon flavor through the chew. It suits puppies that flatten rubber toys quickly but are not yet ready for adult hardness. The two pack matters, because rotation keeps a puppy interested far longer than one toy left permanently on the floor. Supervise closely and retire the chew when the ends wear down.

Pros
  • Puppy softened nylon, not adult hardness
  • Wishbone shape is easy to grip
  • Two pack allows rotation
  • Long lasting for steady chewers
Cons
  • Harder than rubber, so not for every teething puppy
  • Never substitute an adult Benebone for the puppy version
  • Must be retired when worn, to avoid fragments

Check Current Price

Frozen Chew Toys for Teething Puppies: The Trick Most Owners Skip

Frozen chew toys for teething puppies are the single most useful teething trick, and the one most owners underuse. For the timeline of when this phase ends, see our guide to when puppies lose their baby teeth. Cold numbs sore gums, pressure satisfies the urge to gnaw, and a frozen stuffed toy keeps a puppy busy far longer than the same toy at room temperature. Stuff a rubber toy with soaked kibble or plain puppy safe paste and freeze it overnight, soak a fabric stick and freeze it, or freeze a damp washcloth twisted into a rope shape. Always supervise frozen chews, and take any toy away once it thaws, softens, or starts to break apart.

Do not freeze hard bones, antlers, or adult nylon chews for a teething puppy. Freezing makes hard materials even less forgiving, and baby teeth are thinner and more brittle than adult teeth. Cold relief should come from soft rubber, fabric, or a washcloth, never from a frozen hard object.

How to Choose the Right Toy for Your Puppy

Start with size, not brand. A toy should be too large to fit fully in the puppy’s mouth, but light enough for the puppy to carry and hold. Small breeds need the smallest puppy sizes, and large breed puppies still need the puppy formula, just in a larger size. Check the manufacturer’s puppy age guidance and size chart before buying, and size up only when adult teeth have arrived.

Next, match hardness to the puppy in front of you. A gentle chewer does beautifully on soft rubber and fabric. A determined chewer may need puppy nylon, with closer supervision. If you are unsure, start soft: you can always step up in firmness, but you cannot un-crack a tooth. Retire any toy with cracks, missing chunks, or frayed fabric at once, and inspect toys daily during peak teething.

Finally, think about where the toy will be used. A stuffed frozen toy belongs in a crate or on a washable floor. A fabric stick is an indoor, supervised toy. A nylon chew can travel to the garden. Two or three toys in rotation beat a basket full of ignored ones, because novelty itself keeps puppies chewing the right things instead of your furniture.

What to Avoid for Teething Puppies

  • Adult chew toys, including adult KONG, adult Nylabone, and adult Benebone versions. Same brand, different hardness, real tooth fracture risk.
  • Antlers, marrow bones, hooves, and hard nylon bones. Too hard for baby teeth and for many adult teeth as well.
  • Rawhide, which can swell, splinter, and cause blockages if swallowed in pieces.
  • Small toys, squeakers, and parts that fit fully in the mouth. If it can be swallowed, it does not belong in a puppy toy box.
  • Unsupervised chewing on any new toy until you know how fast your puppy destroys it.

Chew toys for puppies, in the wider sense, include all of these categories, but teething puppies are a special case: their teeth are temporary, their gums are sore, and their jaws are still learning how hard to bite. Buying for the mouth your puppy has now, rather than the adult dog it will become, is the decision that protects those adult teeth before they even arrive.

Our verdict is simple. Start with the KONG Puppy Goodie Bone for most puppies, add a freezable option for bad gum days, and step up to puppy nylon only if your puppy destroys rubber quickly. Rotate toys, supervise every new one, and retire worn toys without sentiment. The best chew toys for teething puppies are not the toughest ones on the shelf. They are the softest ones that still survive your particular puppy, used under your eye, and replaced the moment they stop being safe.

Are chew toys for puppies safe to leave out all day?

Soft rubber toys in good condition are usually fine left out, but fabric sticks and nylon chews should be supervised, especially with a new puppy. Inspect every toy daily during teething, and remove anything cracked, frayed, or missing chunks at once, since fragments are the main risk.

Can I give my teething puppy an adult chew toy if it is a large breed?

No. Large breed puppies still have baby teeth, which are thinner and more brittle than adult teeth. Buy the puppy formula in the larger size instead, and switch to adult toys only after the adult teeth have fully arrived, usually around 6 to 7 months.

How often should I replace a puppy chew toy?

Replace on condition, not on a calendar. A lightly used rubber toy can last months, while a fabric stick may need replacing after a few heavy weeks. Check for cracks, worn ends, loose threads, and thinning walls every day, and retire the toy at the first sign of damage.

What are puppy teething toys made of, and which material is safest?

The main materials are soft puppy rubber, puppy softened nylon, and fabric. Soft rubber is the safest starting point for most puppies, fabric is best frozen for sore gums, and puppy nylon suits determined chewers under supervision. Adult hardness in any material is the thing to avoid.

πŸΆπŸ“

Need Local Pet Support or an Open Vet Near You?

Use DaisyDu's free neighborhood tools to find 24/7 open emergency animal hospitals, arrange local playdates, or broadcast a lost pet SOS alert.

🐾
WRITTEN & RESEARCHED BY

DaisyDu Pet Care & Editorial Team

Our guides are crafted using peer-reviewed veterinary literature, AAHA/AVMA clinical guidelines, and force-free positive reinforcement methodologies (such as sub-threshold desensitization). For urgent medical symptoms, always consult a licensed veterinarian immediately.